Woman Injured on Michigan Trail Loses Supreme Court Case
The Michigan Supreme Court says the state has no obligation to maintain a northern Michigan trail, dismissing a lawsuit by a woman who sued after suffering serious back injuries when her off-road vehicle hit a partially buried board.
In a 4-3 decision, the court’s conservative majority said Saturday that the unpaved Little Manistee Trail in Lake County is not a road or highway, a designation that would require the state to maintain it. The court says it reached that conclusion with “little difficulty.”
The three dissenting justices, led by Marilyn Kelly, accused the majority of botching a simple case of statutory interpretation. They noted that the trail has many signs that qualify it as a highway, including stop signs, weight limits and curve warnings.
- Before the Nuclear Verdict: Rethinking How Liability Claims Are Managed
- Will California’s New Smoke Claims Law Create a Recovery Bottleneck?
- Report: Property Claims Face Delays, Are Growing More Complex
- Agentic Intelligence for Claims Dominates New Tech Launches
- Florida Bans Flock Cameras, License Plate Readers From State Roads
- Credit Acceptance Reaches $710M Predatory Auto Lending Settlement With Most States
- The Nation’s Insurance Laboratory: What Liability Trends in California Mean for the Rest of the Country
- Are We Training Claims Adjusters or Claims Processors?