Admitted Drunk, Underage Driver Can Sue Bars, Mass. Court Rules
A Suffolk Superior Court in Boston has ruled that an admittedly drunk underage drinker in Massachusetts can sue two bars that served him alcohol before he was involved in a vehicle crash.
According to Judge Ralph Gants, drunk driver Robert Nunez II, who was 19 at the time of the crash that left him a paraplegic, presented enough evidence that the licensed establishments violated their legal duty not to serve an under-age customer. He wrote:
“In short, since it is a crime for a tavern to serve alcohol to an underage adult, a tavern has a legal duty to not serve alcohol to anyone it knows or reasonably should know is under 21 years of age. That duty is owed not only to any third party injured by the underaged adult but to the underaged adult himself, since the law seeks to protect all persons under 21 from their anticipated inability to drink responsibly. If the underaged adult can prove that a tavern breached that duty, and that he was injured as a result of the alcohol the tavern negligently permitted him to drink, he can obtain damages for the injuries caused by the defendant tavern’s negligence.”
State law allows drunk drivers to sue bars that served them if they show “willful, wanton, or reckless†disregard for their intoxication. However, the judge ruled that because Nunez was underage he only needed to show that the bars were negligent in serving him drinks and thus his case could proceed to trial.
The court reserved for the trial court the question of whether the defendant taverns may claim comparative negligence.
Nunez admitted that he was driving drunk. He contended that he could have avoided the accident if he had not been intoxicated.
- Beyond the Claim: How Social Canvassing is Transforming Insurance Fraud Detection
- Jury Awards $80M to 3 Former Zurich NA Employees for Wrongful Termination
- DraftKings Sued Over ‘Risk-Free’ Bets That Were Anything But
- California Sees Two More Property Insurers Withdraw From Market
- Millions of Recalled Hyundai and Kia Vehicles, With Dangerous Defect, Remain on Road
- Property Restoration Industry: A Culture in Need of Repair?
- Poll: Consumers OK with AI in P/C Insurance, but Not So Much for Claims and Underwriting
- Report: Vehicle Complexity, Labor ‘Reshaping’ Auto Insurance and Collision Repair