Germany-Based Executives Managed Faked VW Emission Test Results
Volkswagen AG executives in Germany controlled the key aspects of emissions tests whose results the carmaker now admits were faked, according to three people familiar with the company’s U.S. operations.
The criteria, outcomes and engineering of cars that missed emissions targets were overseen by managers at Volkswagen’s base in Wolfsburg, according to the people who asked not to be identified because they weren’t authorized to speak publicly.
Their accounts show the chain of command and those involved in the deception stretched to Volkswagen headquarters. While the company has asked German prosecutors to open an investigation, the executive committee of the supervisory board has backed former Chief Executive Martin Winterkorn’s statement that he knew nothing about the malfeasance.
Emissions testers at a site in Westlake Village, California, evaluated all the cars involved according to criteria sent from Germany and translated into English, and all results were sent back to Germany before being passed to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, one of the people said.
If any vehicle failed to meet emissions targets, a team of engineers from Volkswagen headquarters or luxury brand Audi’s base in Ingolstadt was flown in, the person said. After the group had tinkered with the vehicle for about a week, the car would then pass the test. VW had no engineers in the U.S. able to create the mechanism that cheated on the test or who could fix emissions problems, according to two other people.
A spokesman for VW wasn’t immediately available for comment.
Audi development chief Ulrich Hackenberg and Porsche development head Wolfgang Hatz are among those who will leave the company in the wake of Winterkorn’s resignation two days ago, two people familiar with the matter said. The two previously ran units at the heart of the affair – Hackenberg, a Winterkorn confidante, was responsible for VW brand development from 2007 to 2013, while Hatz ran the group’s motor development from 2007 to 2011.
Probes in the U.S. are picking up, with 27 states planning to subpoena the company in a joint investigation, said Eileen Boyce, a spokeswoman for Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan. The states will pursue the investigation under consumer- protection and environmental laws, according to several attorneys general.
The EPA said on Sept. 18 the company admitted it cheated its way through U.S. air pollution tests. It could face fines of as much as $18 billion euros for reporting false results from the VW Jetta, Golf, Beetle and Passat and the Audi A3.
All of the cars found with the software that enabled them to cheat on the tests were evaluated at the Westlake Village site and from 2012 at a larger facility in Oxnard, California, said one of the people. The laboratories there, which used equipment provided by Graz, Austria-based AVL List GmbH, tested cars for VW brands around the world, not just those intended for the U.S. market, the person said.
AVL List spokesman Michael Ksela confirmed that the company supplied equipment for the Oxnard, California site. He ruled out that AVL List staff was involved in Volkswagen’s emissions testing on site.
While it was often the case that lab results showed emission levels of carbon dioxide or nitrogen oxides which differed by 10 percent or 20 percent from road results, the person said tests never showed emissions 35 or 40 times greater than might have been expected, suggesting that any software tweak might have been installed before reaching the Californian testing sites.
(With assistance from Elisabeth Behrmann in Munich, Alexander Weber in Vienna and Chad Thomas in Berlin.)